Alexander Gromnitsky's Blog

Those who want privacy must pay

Latest update:

Tales from the distant past (March 25, 1999 LWN Weekly Edition):

"Larry McVoy is out to change the way cooperative software development is done, and he may just pull it off. …

"Larry's stated goal is to have every free software project using BitKeeper within a few years. He may just get there. … With some luck, the result should be a reduction in the number of "Linus does not scale" burnouts that have occasionally halted kernel work in the past.

"As part of Larry's approach to world domination, he intends that BitKeeper be freely available for any free software development team that wants it. … But Larry also wants commercial software companies to use his system, and he would like for them to pay for the privilege. …

"BitKeeper includes a logging feature. Once multiple repositories are in use, BitKeeper will log all changes to a central server; these logs will be made available via a web page. Thus anybody can go to the web site and see what's happening with any development project out there which is using BitKeeper. …

"The reasoning behind this move is the following: Larry believes that free software projects want their work to be in the open anyway, and will not be bothered by the logging. Since the logging only kicks in when multiple repositories are used, individuals using BitKeeper to manage their diaries will not be affected. Proprietary vendors, instead, are not likely to be happy with having their change log messages broadcast to the world. For them, this restriction will probably make the system unusable.

"At this point Larry shows up with a deal: the commercial version of BitKeeper doesn't do public central logging - you can direct the logging to an internal server. Pay the price, and you can use the system with your privacy intact."


Tags: quote, ойті
Authors: ag